Skip to content

Running Coupling Constants

The strong coupling αs\alpha_s depends on the energy scale μ\mu:

αs(μ)=αs(μ0)1+αs(μ0)12π(332nf)ln(μ2/μ02)\alpha_s(\mu) = \frac{\alpha_s(\mu_0)}{1 + \frac{\alpha_s(\mu_0)}{12\pi}(33 - 2n_f)\ln(\mu^2/\mu_0^2)}

Where nfn_f is the number of active quark flavours.

  • Asymptotic freedom: For nf<17n_f \lt 17, αs\alpha_s decreases at high energies. Quarks behave as nearly free particles at short distances.
  • Confinement: At low energies, αs\alpha_s becomes large, and perturbation theory breaks down. Quarks are confined into hadrons.

The electromagnetic coupling also runs (but increases at high energies):

α(μ)=α(μ0)1α(μ0)3πln(μ2/μ02)\alpha(\mu) = \frac{\alpha(\mu_0)}{1 - \frac{\alpha(\mu_0)}{3\pi}\ln(\mu^2/\mu_0^2)}

The running of coupling constants is governed by the beta function:

β(g)μdgdμ\beta(g) \equiv \mu\frac{dg}{d\mu}

At one-loop order:

QED:

βQED(e)=e312π2βQED(α)=2α23π>0\beta_{\mathrm{QED}(e) = \frac{e^3}{12\pi^2} \quad \Rightarrow \quad \beta_{\mathrm{QED}(\alpha) = \frac{2\alpha^2}{3\pi} \gt 0}}

The positive beta function means the electromagnetic coupling increases with energy (antiscreening).

QCD:

βQCD(gs)=gs316π2(113CA43TFnf)\beta_{\mathrm{QCD}(g_s) = -\frac{g_s^3}{16\pi^2}\left(\frac{11}{3}C_A - \frac{4}{3}T_F n_f\right)}

For SU(3), CA=N=3C_A = N = 3 and TF=1/2T_F = 1/2:

βQCD(gs)=gs316π2(112nf3)\beta_{\mathrm{QCD}(g_s) = -\frac{g_s^3}{16\pi^2}\left(11 - \frac{2n_f}{3}\right)}

The negative sign (for nf<33/2n_f \lt 33/2) means the strong coupling decreases with energy: This is asymptotic freedom (Gross, Wilczek, and Politzer, Nobel Prize 2004).

Interpretation. The gluon self-interaction (the CAC_A term) dominates over fermion screening (the nfn_f term) for the physically relevant number of flavours. Gluons carry colour charge and Therefore antiscreen, leading to the coupling decreasing at short distances.

6.3 Grand Unification and the Unification Scale

Section titled “6.3 Grand Unification and the Unification Scale”

If the three gauge couplings are extrapolated to very high energies, they approximately meet at μ1015\mu \sim 10^{15} GeV (in the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model), suggesting unification into a Simple group such as SU(5) or SO(10).

Example 6.1: Estimating the unification scale

At one loop, the coupling at scale μ\mu is:

αi1(μ)=αi1(μ0)bi2πln(μμ0)\alpha_i^{-1}(\mu) = \alpha_i^{-1}(\mu_0) - \frac{b_i}{2\pi}\ln\left(\frac{\mu}{\mu_0}\right)

Where bib_i are the one-loop beta function coefficients and μ0=mZ91.2\mu_0 = m_Z \approx 91.2 GeV.

For the SM, the coefficients are:

  • b1=41/(10π)b_1 = -41/(10\pi) for U(1)Y\mathrm{U}(1)_Y (properly normalised)
  • b2=19/(6π)b_2 = -19/(6\pi) for SU(2)L\mathrm{SU}(2)_L
  • b3=7/πb_3 = -7/\pi for SU(3)C\mathrm{SU}(3)_C

At the unification scale MGUTM_{\mathrm{GUT}}All three couplings are equal: α11(MGUT)=α21(MGUT)=α31(MGUT)\alpha_1^{-1}(M_{\mathrm{GUT}) = \alpha_2^{-1}(M_{\mathrm{GUT}) = \alpha_3^{-1}(M_{\mathrm{GUT})}}}.

Setting α11=α21\alpha_1^{-1} = \alpha_2^{-1}:

\alpha_1^{-1}(m_Z) - \alpha_2^{-1}(m_Z) = \frac{b_2 - b_1}{2\pi}\ln\left(\frac{M_{\mathrm{GUT}}{m_Z}\right)}

With α11(mZ)59.0\alpha_1^{-1}(m_Z) \approx 59.0, α21(mZ)29.6\alpha_2^{-1}(m_Z) \approx 29.6:

59.0 - 29.6 = \frac{b_2 - b_1}{2\pi}\ln\left(\frac{M_{\mathrm{GUT}}{m_Z}\right)}

This gives MGUT1013M_{\mathrm{GUT} \sim 10^{13}}101610^{16} GeV depending on the precise Coefficients and the inclusion of threshold corrections. In the MSSM, the modified beta Coefficients give a much cleaner unification at MGUT2×1016M_{\mathrm{GUT} \sim 2 \times 10^{16}} GeV.

:::caution Common Pitfall The Standard Model couplings do not meet at a single point when extrapolated using SM beta Functions. The three lines form a rough triangle. It is only in supersymmetric extensions (MSSM) That the additional superpartner contributions to the beta functions bring the three couplings to Near-convergence. This convergence is often cited as indirect evidence for supersymmetry.

:::

  • The beta function encodes how a coupling changes with energy scale.
  • A negative beta function means asymptotic freedom; a positive one means screening.
  • The running of αs\alpha_s is measured precisely at e+ee^+e^- colliders and deep inelastic scattering.
  • The Landau pole in QED marks the scale where perturbation theory breaks down.
  • Confusing the sign convention: β(g)>0\beta(g) > 0 means the coupling increases with energy.
  • Assuming that asymptotic freedom implies confinement automatically. They are related but distinct phenomena.
  • Forgetting that the number of active flavours nfn_f depends on the energy scale relative to quark masses.
  • Using the one-loop formula far beyond its validity range where higher-order corrections are significant.
  • Collider physics: Precision measurements of αs\alpha_s at the Z pole and LHC constrain the Standard Model.
  • Lattice QCD: Numerical simulations compute αs\alpha_s non-perturbatively from first principles.
  • Cosmology: The running of couplings affects primordial nucleosynthesis and baryogenesis models.
  • Dark matter searches: The scale dependence of αs\alpha_s influences the calculation of hadronic backgrounds.

6.7 Worked Example: Estimating αs\alpha_s at Different Scales

Section titled “6.7 Worked Example: Estimating αs\alpha_sαs​ at Different Scales”

Problem. Given αs(mZ)=0.118\alpha_s(m_Z) = 0.118 at μ0=mZ=91.2\mu_0 = m_Z = 91.2 GeV, estimate αs\alpha_s at μ=1\mu = 1 TeV.

Solution

At one loop with nf=5n_f = 5 active flavours:

αs(μ)=αs(μ0)1+αs(μ0)12π(332nf)ln(μ2/μ02)\alpha_s(\mu) = \frac{\alpha_s(\mu_0)}{1 + \frac{\alpha_s(\mu_0)}{12\pi}(33 - 2n_f)\ln(\mu^2/\mu_0^2)}

=0.1181+0.11812π(3310)ln(10002/91.22)= \frac{0.118}{1 + \frac{0.118}{12\pi}(33 - 10)\ln(1000^2/91.2^2)}

=0.1181+0.11837.70(23)(4.80)= \frac{0.118}{1 + \frac{0.118}{37.70}(23)(4.80)}

=0.1181+0.0352= \frac{0.118}{1 + 0.0352}

=0.1181.0352=0.114= \frac{0.118}{1.0352} = 0.114.

The coupling decreases from 0.118 to 0.114, consistent with asymptotic freedom. \blacksquare